Gothamist

A non-profit newsroom, powered by WNYC.

Gothamist

WNYC Listen Live

Donate

 

 

News

Trial Raises Questions About Hate Crime Definition


By

Jen Chung

Published Jun 20, 2007

Modified Mar 7, 2008


Share

FacebookTwitterRedditEmail


Never miss a story

 Email address

By submitting your information, you're agreeing to receive communications from New York Public Radio in accordance with our Terms .


By

Jen Chung

Published Jun 20, 2007

Modified Mar 7, 2008


Share

FacebookTwitterRedditEmail


We rely on your support to make local news available to all

Make your contribution now and help Gothamist thrive in 2026. Donate today

Gothamist is funded by sponsors and member donations

Last October, the Brooklyn DA's office charged three men with murder as a hate crime after a gay man they had lured, beat, robbed and chased into traffic died from his injuries. But now the trio's lawyers claim that it was not a hate crime, but a crime of opportunity.

Anthony Fortunato, John Fox, and Ilya Shurov are on trial for the murder of 29-year-old Michael Sandy; the three went to a gay chat room to lure Sandy to Plum Beach. Gerald DiChiara, one of the defense lawyers, wrote, "He was targeted because he would (a) come alone, (b) bring drugs and/or money for drugs with him, (c) go to a deserted spot and (d) probably not offer much resistance...Consequently, the crimes alleged are not crimes of hate but rather crimes of opportunity." The NY Times noted how prosecutor Seth Lieberman answered:

In his response, Mr. Lieberman began with an end run around the defense motion: He conceded that the grand jury had seen no evidence of hatred for gay men, but argued that Justice Konviser-Levine had approved the indictment, thus implicitly rejecting the same defense arguments.

In addition, he argued, if lawmakers had intended to make prosecutors prove defendants hated their victims, the Legislature would have said so in the law’s final language.

“By contrast with New York State,” Mr. Lieberman wrote, “other states have hate crime statutes that require evidence of bias, animus or prejudice.”

Citing legal scholars, he suggested that hate crime prosecutions without evidence of hatred could benefit society. As in the era of racially motivated lynching, he noted, prosecutors could alter perceptions of vulnerability among certain groups and impunity among others.

What's interesting is the DiChiara suggested that if hate crimes didn't have to have the hate proven, then crimes against the elderly, women and immigrants could hypothetically then be classified as hate crime - because age was added to the NY State definition of a hate crime in 2000.

Tagged

Anthony Fortunato

As

brooklyn

brooklyn da

crime

drugs

elderly

fox

gay

grand jury

hate crime

Ilya Shurov

immigrants

John Fox

Last October

law

Michael Sandy

money

murder

new york

new york state

ny state

ny times

Plum Beach

The NY

the ny times

traffic


Jen Chung

Jen Chung is a former WNYC and Gothamist editor.

Read more

Gothamist is funded by sponsors and member donations


Gothamist is funded by sponsors and member donations


MORE news

Exclusive video shows shocking moment Brooklyn building collapsed

An in-home surveillance camera shows two children swept up in the wreckage.

By

David Brand

Published Nov 12, 2026 at 4:33 p.m. ET


Why Brooklynites Jeffries and Schumer are still favorites to lead Democrats in Congress

One big reason: no one has formally stepped up to challenge either lawmaker.

By

Brigid Bergin

News

Why Brooklynites Jeffries and Schumer are still favorites to lead Democrats in Congress

One big reason: no one has formally stepped up to challenge either lawmaker.

By

Brigid Bergin


Bronx grand jury to weigh charges against teen in fatal shooting of 15-year-old

By

Samantha Max

Tornado watch in effect for 11 NJ counties, flash flood warning in Queens

By

Giulia Heyward

NYC Council passes ban on 'surveillance pricing' that relies on personal data

By

Elizabeth Kim


Never miss a story

Catch up on the most important headlines with a roundup of essential NYC stories, delivered to your inbox daily.

Sign upEmail address

By submitting your information, you're agreeing to receive communications from New York Public Radio in accordance with our Terms .