Gothamist

A non-profit newsroom, powered by WNYC.

Gothamist

WNYC Listen Live

Donate

 

 

News

Lawyers take aim at NYPD gun search policy 2 years after Supreme Court ruling


By

Samantha Max

Published Jun 28, 2024


Share

FacebookTwitterRedditEmail


Never miss a story

 Email address

By submitting your information, you're agreeing to receive communications from New York Public Radio in accordance with our Terms .

Passersby walk past a gun-free zone signboard near Times Square.  New York State started to prohibit concealed carry of weapons in designated sensitive areas, including Times Square, bars, libraries, schools, government buildings and hospitals, across the state after the U.S. Supreme Court struck down the state's century-old concealed carry weapons law.

 

(Photo by Michael Nagle/Xinhua via Getty Images)


By

Samantha Max

Published Jun 28, 2024


Share

FacebookTwitterRedditEmail


We rely on your support to make local news available to all

Make your contribution now and help Gothamist thrive in 2026. Donate today

Gothamist is funded by sponsors and member donations

Two years after a landmark Supreme Court ruling ordered New York to make it easier for people to carry concealed firearms, legal experts say New York City has not become the Wild West version of itself some gun safety advocates had feared.

But they say some cracks have formed in the city’s long-held efforts to prevent gun violence by keeping as many guns as possible off the streets.

There’s no doubt that more people are now applying for permits to carry guns in public. NYPD data show applications for concealed carry permits have surged since the U.S. Supreme Court ruled on the case, New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen, two years ago this month.

But it’s unclear how many more people are actually licensed to carry guns in the city, because the NYPD won’t disclose how many of those applications the department has approved.

Law enforcement, lawyers and judges are also wading through murky legal questions about whether the federal ruling should — or will — change the way police search for illegal guns on city streets. At issue is whether police should assume people they encounter with firearms are carrying them illegally, even though the Supreme Court has bolstered the right to carry a gun.

“I think this is very unsettled law,” said Peter Tilem, a lawyer who regularly represents gun owners in criminal and civil cases.

Complications for police

Getting illegal guns off the streets is a central priority for law enforcement in New York City — one that has become even more pronounced since Mayor Eric Adams was elected on promises to address a pandemic-era surge in gun violence.

The NYPD’s crime statistics website boasts the number of guns seized by police since Adams took office in 2022 (more than 16,900 to date). The mayor has revived controversial NYPD teams tasked with finding unlicensed firearms. Local prosecutors have also prioritized gun cases and vowed to hold people accountable for carrying illegal guns.

The NYPD did not respond to questions about whether the department has updated its training or policies for gun searches and seizures since the Supreme Court decision. In an emailed statement, an unnamed spokesperson said: “The NYPD remains committed to keeping illegal guns off of the streets and respects the rights of all New Yorkers.”

Retired NYPD Deputy Chief Robert Lukach said he expects the Bruen decision has made it more difficult for officers to seize guns. Before the Supreme Court ruling, the threshold for carrying a concealed firearm in New York was so high that police officers could assume nearly anyone they stopped with a gun was carrying it illegally, Lukach said.

He said he learned as an officer to look for bulges in pockets, backpacks and waistbands. Seeing a bulge meant he could pat someone down. And if Lukach felt a weapon, he could take it and make an arrest. He remembered once arresting someone after pulling up to a scene and clearly seeing the shape of a gun in the man’s fanny pack.

It’s still illegal to carry guns in many places across the state, known as “sensitive locations.” Lawmakers passed legislation days after the Supreme Court ruling that barred even most permit holders from bringing firearms to schools, subways, Times Square and other places they considered too risky to carry a weapon.

But outside of sensitive locations, police now have to expect more people are carrying licensed guns, Lukach said. If officers want to search someone, they have to carefully assess whether they have probable cause to believe the person has a firearm, and that it’s illegal.

Lukach said that puts police in a bind. If officers rush to search someone, they could violate the person’s rights and arrest them for a case that will ultimately be thrown out in court. But if they take too much time to evaluate whether someone is carrying an unlicensed gun, they could get hurt.

“If I was to do it, my presumption at any given time is going to be that I presume that the gun is carried illegally,” he said. “I can't presume that it's carried legally, because I think if you do, you kind of put yourself in harm's way.”

Jury’s still out on ruling’s impact in the courts

Some defense attorneys argue that since the Supreme Court decision, police should first assume that people are carrying a gun legally — not the other way around. Lawyers have filed a small but growing number of motions asking the courts to dismiss gun possession cases and block recovered guns from being used as evidence if they think police seized them unlawfully.

The state Office of Court Administration said it did not have data on how many times defense attorneys have used the Supreme Court ruling to argue for gun evidence to be suppressed or cases to be dismissed. Some district attorney’s offices in the five boroughs said defense attorneys have started using the ruling to challenge their clients’ gun cases. But Gothamist was only able to identify one state court case in the Bronx that has been dismissed. The DA’s office plans to appeal the judge’s decision.

A federal judge in Brooklyn has also sided with a man, Robert Homer, who was arrested after police watched him put a gun in his pocket. Officers said they assumed that he was carrying the gun illegally, because they said he didn’t display the “discipline” that would be expected from a licensed carrier. In that case, United States v. Homer, District Judge Nicholas Garaufis said placing a gun in a pants pocket instead of in a holster does not give police grounds to arrest someone.

Dan Feldman, a professor at John Jay College of Criminal Justice, said the Homer case is unique, because a detective told the court that the only thing suspicious about the man’s behavior was that he put a gun in his pocket. But he doesn’t think most arguments connected to the Supreme Court ruling will win in court, because police can often point to other factors that led them to search and arrest someone with a gun.

Feldman also said many defendants opt to plead guilty in gun cases rather than argue their legal merits in court, because people who lose risk long prison sentences. The minimum sentence for second-degree criminal possession of a weapon — a class C felony — is 3-and-a-half years, and the maximum is 15.

“They don't want to sit in Rikers. They'll plead to something to get it over with,” Feldman said. “If there's some chance that they'll get convicted, that may not be a chance they want to take.”

New York’s highest court declined to weigh in on six arguments related to the Supreme Court ruling last fall, because of a legal technicality. But one Court of Appeals judge wrote a dissent warning her colleagues that the court can’t put off the issue much longer if it wants to protect New Yorkers from gun violence.

“We are in uncharted and dangerous territory, waiting to see how the law will develop in this post-Bruen era. But with or without the Supreme Court’s introspection, it falls to the rest of the federal and state judiciary to determine what legislatures may do to curb gun violence,” Judge Jenny Rivera wrote. “For now, the majority has merely delayed resolution of these first Bruen-spawned challenges to our State’s gun laws.”

Bahar Ostadan contributed reporting.

Tagged

new york city

public safety


Samantha Max

Samantha reports on whether New Yorkers feel safe and whether the institutions that are supposed to protect them are working. Before coming to WNYC/Gothamist, she spent three years covering the criminal justice system in Tennessee for Nashville Public Radio. Her reporting on Nashville's police department received multiple awards, including the Daniel Schorr Journalism Prize. Samantha was also part of the inaugural class of Report for America, a service journalism program that sends up-and-coming reporters to local newsrooms across the country. She is a Northwestern University grad, a Baltimore native and fluent in Spanish. Got a tip? Email [email protected] or Signal: samanthamaxwnyc.93.

Read more

Gothamist is funded by sponsors and member donations


Gothamist is funded by sponsors and member donations


MORE news

NYC bill would require food delivery firms to fund fixes to the e-bike 'crisis'

Uber Eats, Grubhub and DoorDash would have to pay for worker hubs and e-bike storage areas.

By

Arya Sundaram

Published Nov 12, 2026 at 8:01 a.m. ET


Death toll from Brooklyn building collapse continues to rise amid ongoing search

At least 8 people were dead and 25 injured Thursday morning

By

Brittany Kriegstein

and

Verónica Del Valle

News

Death toll from Brooklyn building collapse continues to rise amid ongoing search

At least 8 people were dead and 25 injured Thursday morning

By

Brittany Kriegstein

and

Verónica Del Valle


North Brooklyn street redesign paves the way for NYC's 'low-traffic neighborhood' plan

By

Liam Quigley

Brooklyn building collapse: 4 dead, 7 children among at least 23 injured

By

Elizabeth Shwe

,

Hannah Frishberg

,

David Brand

and

Liam Quigley

Manhattan’s East Side loses another movie theater to development

By

Hannah Frishberg


Never miss a story

Catch up on the most important headlines with a roundup of essential NYC stories, delivered to your inbox daily.

Sign upEmail address

By submitting your information, you're agreeing to receive communications from New York Public Radio in accordance with our Terms .