Gothamist

A non-profit newsroom, powered by WNYC.

Gothamist

WNYC Listen Live

Donate

 

 

Arts & Entertainment

980 Madison Avenue: Visionary or Invasive?


By

Jill Priluck

Published Oct 25, 2006

Modified Mar 7, 2008


Share

FacebookTwitterRedditEmail


Never miss a story

 Email address

By submitting your information, you're agreeing to receive communications from New York Public Radio in accordance with our Terms .


By

Jill Priluck

Published Oct 25, 2006

Modified Mar 7, 2008


Share

FacebookTwitterRedditEmail


We rely on your support to make local news available to all

Make your contribution now and help Gothamist thrive in 2026. Donate today

Gothamist is funded by sponsors and member donations

2006_10_normanfoster.JPG

Yesterday's Landmarks Preservation Commission hearing over 980 Madison Ave. was a relatively staid affair. On the second floor of the Surrogate's Court building on Chambers Street, Lord Norman Foster told the 150-plus audience that 980 Madison Ave. was about one thing: regeneration.

But Foster, wearing a bubblegum pink tie, took it one step further, characterizing the Upper East Side as a neighborhood with "a tradition of radicalism." He compared 980 Madison Ave.'s role, architecturally, to that of its possible neighbor, the Carlyle Hotel, circa 1930, given the brownstones it replaced. He also cited the Whitney and Guggenheim as evidence of the area's "tradition of change."

About 50 speakers took to the microphone. Approximately half opposed the project, including representatives from Friends of the Upper East Side, the Historic Districts Council and City Council member Daniel Garodnick's office. The building is not harmonious with the area's landmarks, they claimed, and the glass and steel building will only lead to more, thereby defeating the purpose of a historic district. One resident compared 980 Madison Ave. to the invasion of the British Redcoats during the revolutionary war. Another said that approving the proposal would be "like the Philharmonic inviting a heavy metal punk rocker to join the orchestra."

Artist Jeff Koons, billionaire businessman Ron Perelman, architect Richard Meier, gallery owner Larry Gagosian (a prospective 980 Madison Ave. commercial tenant) and other neighborhood residents who support the project bemoaned what they called the change-averse stance of preservationists who oppose it. One Upper East Side dermatologist with a self-described "strong eye for detail" called 980 Madison Ave. a "gem."

2006_10_980mtg1.JPG

The 22-story tower certainly has interesting features that will cement the area as a destination for arts and culture: a 24,000 square-foot public art exhibition space and a 10,000 square-foot public sculpture garden. One can't deny the benefits of restoring the limestone Parke-Bernet Gallery building built by Walker & Poor in 1949. And we wonder why glass has become the enemy when, as historic-preservation consultant Bill Higgins explained, "by now the tradition of glass as a contemporary material that works well in historical context is one that has been established not by this commission but worldwide."

We also understand why a mostly low-rise district isn't welcoming developer Aby Rosen's project. We live in one of those areas ourselves and we certainly wouldn't want one glass and steel high rise to serve as a mandate for more of the same - we like our low-level buildings. Of course, a glass and steel tower is something we sometimes can't prevent.

Really, the heart of the matter, as co-chair of the Defenders of the Upper East Side Teri Slater put it, is whether, according to Section 74-711 of the New York City Zoning Resolution, the building contributes to a preservation purpose.

2006_10_fosterrosen2.JPG

So, are Foster and developer Aby Rosen visionaries or invaders? Should the LPC commissioners approve or reject the plan?

And, if you're craving more, read The New York Sun, The New York Times, the Daily Intelligencer, or the Post.

Photos by Jill Priluck

Tagged

Aby Rosen

architecture

art

arts

carlyle hotel

chambers street

city

City Council

court

culture

Daily Intelligencer

District

east side

friends

heavy metal

jeff koons

Jill Priluck

landmarks

landmarks preservation commission

Madison Ave

new york

new york city

New York Sun

new york times

Norman Foster

photos

public art

richard meier

Ron Perelman

sculpture

The New York

The New York Sun

the new york times

Upper East

upper east side


Jill Priluck

Read more

Gothamist is funded by sponsors and member donations


Gothamist is funded by sponsors and member donations


MORE arts-entertainment

An expert guide to navigating the Fulton Center subway frankenstation

Bonus tip: There's a Krispy Kreme.

By

Elizabeth Shwe

and

James Ramsay

Published Nov 12, 2026


A good bet: New Yorkers are lining up to become casino dealers

Learn to deal blackjack and you'll always been employed.

By

Hannah Frishberg

Arts & Entertainment

A good bet: New Yorkers are lining up to become casino dealers

Learn to deal blackjack and you'll always been employed.

By

Hannah Frishberg


Long-lost Georgia O’Keeffe painting found in East Village closet

By

Hannah Frishberg

The real race at the NYC Marathon is getting to the front of the toilet line

By

Samantha Max

On HBO's 'The Gilded Age,' Ben Ahlers is New York high society’s man of the hour

By

Sonia Rao


Never miss a story

Catch up on the most important headlines with a roundup of essential NYC stories, delivered to your inbox daily.

Sign upEmail address

By submitting your information, you're agreeing to receive communications from New York Public Radio in accordance with our Terms .